Rugby fans, brace yourselves for a shocking revelation: one of England’s top tacklers, Sam Underhill, topped the missed tackle chart in Bath’s recent clash against RC Toulon. But here’s where it gets controversial—was it a momentary lapse or a sign of deeper issues? Let’s dive into the player ratings from Bath’s 45-34 defeat in the Investec Champions Cup, where standout performances and unexpected shortcomings collided in a thrilling match.
Backs
15 Santiago Carreras: The Argentine fullback showcased his flair with 81 metres gained and three defenders beaten, but his defensive lapses, including a missed tackle on Gael Drean for Toulon’s crucial try, left much to be desired. And this is the part most people miss—despite his world-class reputation, turnovers and defensive struggles marred his performance. (Rating: 6)
14 Joe Cokanasiga: The towering winger dominated under the high ball, securing early catches to set up attacks. His physicality was key in rucks and defense, though limited attacking opportunities prevented him from truly shining. (Rating: 7)
13 Max Ojomoh: It’s baffling this talent was overlooked internationally for so long. Ojomoh was Bath’s creative linchpin, highlighted by his no-look pass for Louie Hennessey’s try. A masterclass in playmaking. (Rating: 7)
12 Cameron Redpath: While Ojomoh supported attacks, Redpath was the defensive anchor, making nine crucial tackles. His lack of attacking involvement was offset by his ability to stifle Toulon’s momentum. (Rating: 7)
11 Henry Arundell: A first-half break showcased his European-class footwork, while a try-saving tackle proved his defensive worth. Limited chances, but maximum impact. (Rating: 6)
10 Finn Russell: Scotland’s fly-half uncharacteristically focused on defense, weathering Toulon’s onslaught. His attacking magic emerged sparingly, notably in setting up Carreras’ try, but the absence of Ben Spencer seemed to weigh on him. (Rating: 7)
9 Tom Carr-Smith: Stepping in for Spencer, Carr-Smith brought creativity and pace but lacked control. His role in Bath’s third try was brilliant, yet fans questioned if he could match Spencer’s game management. (Rating: 6)
Forwards
8 Alfie Barbeary: Typically an impact sub, Barbeary proved he’s a starter with powerful runs and all-around influence. Bath’s standout performer. (Rating: 8)
7 Sam Underhill: Here’s the controversy—England’s tackling machine missed three tackles, an anomaly for a player of his caliber. His ball-carrying was strong, but defensive lapses were uncharacteristic. (Rating: 5)
6 Ted Hill: A well-taken try and dominant lineout wins highlighted his performance, but three turnovers to Toulon were costly at this level. (Rating: 7)
5 Ross Molony: A disappointing showing from the former Leinster lock, with minimal impact beyond a few lineouts and tackles. (Rating: 5)
4 Quinn Roux: Ineffective and error-prone, conceding penalties and missing key tackles. A performance to forget. (Rating: 4)
3 Billy Sela: Despite an early scrum penalty, the young prop held his own, showcasing potential in a challenging role. (Rating: 6)
2 Tom Dunn: Bath’s stalwart delivered solid hits, though lineout struggles were more Toulon’s doing than his own. (Rating: 6)
1 Beno Obano: Penalized early but recovered well in a fascinating duel with Kyle Sinckler. A steady performance. (Rating: 6)
Replacements: Bath’s inexperienced bench impressed, with Ewan Richards setting up Arthur Green’s try and Louie Hennessey finishing Ojomoh’s pass brilliantly. Yet, Toulon’s experience ultimately prevailed. (Rating: 7)
Thought-provoking question: Is Sam Underhill’s missed tackle performance a one-off, or does it signal a broader issue in Bath’s defensive strategy? Share your thoughts below—let’s spark a debate!
